Home / Ice cream menu

Ice cream in Greencastle, PA:
milkshakes & sundaes

Save room for something sweet.

Lizzy’s is a locally owned ice cream shop and restaurant in Greencastle, Pennsylvania, serving hand-dipped scoops, soft serve, thick milkshakes, candy-filled Twisters and signature sundaes.

Order online Call 717-597-2888

Flavor alert: Hand-dipped flavors and seasonal desserts rotate. Check online ordering or call for today's selection and current prices. Photos include seasonal specials.

Lizzy’s fall desserts with a sundae in a foam bowl and drinks in takeaway cups

Seasonal spotlight

A little taste of fall

Something sweet for sweater weather. Take a look at these fall favorites from Lizzy’s.

Seasonal treats change—check our latest specials or give us a call for today’s availability.

See our latest specials Call 717-597-2888

Ice Cream

Choose soft serve or one of our hand-dipped flavors in a cup or cone.

View hand-dipped flavors

Explore our scoops, from familiar favorites to something a little different. Flavors rotate; check Toast for today’s selection and current prices.

Banana Pudding

Banana flavor, marshmallow ribbons and pieces of vanilla wafer cookie.

Better Brownie Batter

Brownie-batter ice cream layered with fudge and brownie bites.

Black Cherry

Cherry-filled scoops with a rich black-cherry flavor.

Blueberry Cheesecake

Cheesecake pieces and blueberry sauce in a cheesecake-flavored scoop.

Butter Pecan

Buttery scoops studded with roasted pecans.

Cappuccino Crunch

Coffee flavor with dark-chocolate swirls and crunchy almond toffee.

Chocolate

A creamy scoop full of chocolate flavor.

Chocolate Peanut Butter

Chocolate and peanut butter in one scoop.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

Cookie-dough chunks and chocolate chips in a vanilla base.

Cotton Candy

Pink-and-blue scoops with sweet cotton-candy flavor.

Cookies & Cream

Vanilla studded with chunks of cream-filled cookies.

Extreme Chocolate

A deeply chocolatey, dark-chocolate-flavored scoop.

Grapenut

Crunchy Grape Nuts cereal in creamy vanilla.

Midnight Caramel River

Golden vanilla meets dark chocolate, threaded with caramel.

Mint Chip

Refreshing mint flavor dotted with chocolate chips.

Moose Tracks

Vanilla with mini peanut-butter cups and Moose Tracks fudge.

Peanut Butter Twist

Vanilla with ribbons of peanut butter.

Playdough

Yellow vanilla dotted with pink-and-blue sugar-cookie pieces.

Raspberry

A fruity scoop flavored with raspberry puree.

Salty Caramel Truffle

Caramel ice cream with a sweet-and-salty caramel swirl and chocolate caramel truffles.

Strawberry

Creamy strawberry flavor with real strawberry pieces.

Superman

A colorful combination of strawberry, banana and Blue Moon.

Tipsy Peach

Peach flavor, bourbon-caramel ribbons and cinnamon-oatmeal clusters.

Vanilla

Smooth and creamy classic vanilla.

Pumpkin

Pumpkin flavor rounded out with warming spices.

Milkshakes

Classic shakes blended thick and smooth, plus over-the-top Lizzy’s signatures.

Classic MilkshakeVanilla, chocolate, raspberry, strawberry, banana, Oreo, coffee, peanut butter, strawberry-banana, cherry or butterscotch.
Hand-Dipped MilkshakeTurn any available hand-dipped flavor into a shake.
Reese’s Overload ShakeReese’s Cup, Reese’s Pieces and peanut butter sauce with peanut-butter-infused whipped cream.
Oreo Fudge River ShakeOreo crumbles and hot fudge with Oreo-infused whipped cream and chocolate sprinkles.
Turtle ShakeCaramel, hot fudge and pecans topped with whipped cream.
Cookie Explosion ShakeOreo crumbles, Chips Ahoy crumbles, hot fudge and M&M’s with Oreo-infused whipped cream.

Twisters

Soft serve blended with your favorite candy, cookie, fruit or sauce.

Build Your Own TwisterChoose toppings such as Oreo, Butterfinger, Heath, cookie dough, Reese’s, M&M’s, pineapple, strawberry, banana chips, Fruity Pebbles and more.
Cookies n’ Cream Fudge DreamChocolate soft serve with Oreos, fresh-baked brownies and hot fudge, topped with Oreo-infused whipped cream and chocolate sprinkles.
Dirty Boots TwisterTwist soft serve with cookie dough, brownie pieces, hot fudge and peanut butter, topped with peanut-butter-infused whipped cream and chocolate drizzle.

Sundaes

Start with soft serve or hand-dipped ice cream, then add a favorite topping—or go signature.

Classic SundaeChoose brownie, caramel, chocolate, hot fudge, marshmallow, Oreo, peanut butter, pineapple, raspberry, Reese’s, strawberry and more.
Fried CheesecakeVanilla soft serve with cinnamon-sugar fried cheesecake triangles and your choice of fruit topping.
Sweet Potato MapleVanilla soft serve with cinnamon-sugar sweet potato puffs and maple syrup.
The TurtleVanilla soft serve with caramel, hot fudge and pecans.
UnicornCotton candy ice cream with raspberry sauce, marshmallow sauce and rainbow sprinkles.
Oreo Fudge RiverTwist soft serve with Oreo crumbles, hot fudge, chocolate sprinkles and Oreo-infused whipped cream.
CampfireTwist soft serve with chocolate-covered waffle fries, graham-cracker dust and marshmallow sauce.
Strawberry BaconVanilla soft serve with fresh strawberries, bacon bits and chocolate syrup drizzle.
Greencastle Kinder SurpriseTwist soft serve with Oreo crumbles, Chips Ahoy crumbles, hot fudge, M&M’s and Oreo-infused whipped cream.
Reese’s OverloadVanilla soft serve with Reese’s Cup, Reese’s Pieces and peanut butter sauce with peanut-butter-infused whipped cream.

Ice Cream in Greencastle, PA: Frequently Asked Questions

Helpful answers before your visit to Lizzy’s.

Does Lizzy’s serve both hand-dipped ice cream and soft serve?Yes. Choose from rotating hand-dipped flavors or chocolate, vanilla and twist soft serve in a cup or cone.
Can I get a milkshake made with hand-dipped ice cream?Yes. Any currently available hand-dipped flavor can be blended into a thick milkshake.
Can I order Lizzy’s ice cream online?Yes. Use our online ordering menu for current availability, pickup and delivery options, or call 717-597-2888.
Where is Lizzy’s ice cream shop?Visit us at 2753 Buchanan Trail West, Greencastle, PA 17225. We are open daily from 11 AM to 9 PM.

See current prices & order